Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Invitation to Join a New Facebook Group

Polish Rider by Rembrandt source: Wikipedia 

A blog reader, who chooses to remain anonymous, has begun a facebook group. He extends the following invitation:

To all who are interested in discussing the Bieganski stereotype and ways to defeat it:

On Danusha Goska's blog I have read many incredible stories by many authors. Danusha's articulation of the concept of Bieganski brings clarity to many questions that most of us have had for our entire lives. The authors who contribute to her blog, the guest writers and members, can share their stories with a wider audience. Facebook is possibly the widest audience on the internet. I will do my part to spread awareness of this group to spark discussion on the internet.

Perhaps some of our other readers and contributors on this blog may be interested.

If Bieganski rears his brutish head, we can archive and save the posts for posterity. We can have a 'Hall of Shame', a compendium of trolls and their pathologies. We can show audiences across the internet how sad they are, what sadness drives them to hate.

It will affect people as it has affected me; remember, I was not so aware of Bieganski for most of my life, it seemed so uncanny, that it couldn't be real, it couldn't be true that so many people could hate, fear or disparage a person for being a Bohunk. But it is true.

Anyway, we can also archive positive discussions too. We can archive hopefulness and optimism and education and awareness and dignity.

If anybody here is interested, please comment and discuss with us on Facebook here.


  1. I would like to propose the following project: That this blog publish the reasons why various public libraries refuse to buy Dr. Goska's "Bieganski", or Nadja Tesich's "Native Land", "To Die in Chicago", and "Shadow Partisan".

    This as a way to get a handle on the redlining of books treating the Slavic experience as seen by Slavs themselves, rather than as seen just by various Slavophobes.

    Note the following response given for not buying Bieganski, by some of our multicultural progressive library friends.


    Thank you for your recent recommendation to add the following to
    our collection:

    Bieganski by Danusha Goska

    We value your recommendations and evaluate each one carefully.
    However, we have decided not to purchase and add this item to our
    collection due to one of the following reasons:

    Item does not fit within the Library's Collection Development Policy,



  2. And another library refusal to buy Nadja Tesich's -- (like Dr. Goska, another person with such bad taste to have not just one, but two Slavic sounding names) -- books "To Die in Chicago" and "Shadow Partisan"

    I am sorry to disappoint you but there does not appear to be sufficient justification either by the author’s reputation or the subject of her work to justify we purchase the works you have asked that we consider. 

    Now if one were to go thru the holdings of these libraries, I think it would be easy to find many, many books whose content (for other ethnic groups) is actually indistinguishable in terms of style and method, and whose authors are of no greater reputation.

    Such a collection policy, if pursued for other authors would probably exclude all first time authors who usually have no reputation, except for that created by their marketing machines.

    Just another example of the redlining of Slavic authors and books from our multicultural, committed to diversity, against censorship friends of the public library.


  3. In my case, having read and reviewed BIEGANSKI, I donated my copy to a local state university library. They accepted it, even though they commonly reject many donated books to the library, and sell them instead. Perhaps the fact that the university has many Polish students influenced their decision.

  4. Polish Americans and other Polonians committed to the fight against stereotyping should buy and read Bieganski, review it on Amazon, and invite me to speak.

    Bieganski is certainly found in libraries. My local library -- not in a Polish community -- bought a copy and invited me to speak. No problem.

    Please no more library conspiracy theory posts. Bieganski rises or falls on Polish Americans' support. There is zero need to scapegoat any other group for Polish Americans' actions.

    1. Not theory Dr. Goska. This is called data. I am sharing it here. I have seen this before.

      Note how lame their justifications are. Probably 80% of books could be excluded from library collections on these grounds.

      I actually DID take action, and asked libraries to buy books by Polam authors. (They do this for other groups you know.)

      What I DIDN'T do is fall for the double standard of Poles have to buy their own books, AND everyone else's.

      Local libraries are a special case, and ought not to be confused with general trends.

      I am talking about accountability to the public, of which Slavs are part of. Not scapegoating, just responsibility to part of the public, as they observe for others.

      The use of the term scapegoating, when all we are asking for is what others get, subverts the notion that libraries should be accountable to us too. As if we were doing something wrong to request that they stock books on our history and experience too.


    2. As an example of how some people must not be allowed to succeed, and how some others must be facilitated in doing so, you might find the DVD titled "Burzynski" of particular interest. Note the credentials of the guy.

      A familiar script?


  5. And if you watch the DVD "Burzynski", it has a haunting similarity to the exceptional prosecution of Eddie Slovik. Some people must be made examples of. Sort of like Steinbeck's "The Moon is Down"

    (re: Eddie Slovik: remember that American bomber crews in WW2 would on occasion take asylum in Sweden or Switzerland it is said -- they did not paddle like the guy in Catch 22 (?Rossarian?) -- but flew in) I have not heard of any of them being shot. Might be an interesting history project. Whatever happened to the American flyers who escaped the war (and desperate carnage in the air) into Sweden or Switzerland? Prosecuted? Repatriated? other?


  6. ah, and the response of the American Establishment groups to Burzynski seems hauntingly similar to the same Establishment response to Nicola Tesla 100 years before (same Slavophobia I suspect - this stuff does NOT change, at least for us), as well described in the DVD "Tesla, Master of Lightning." check 'em out, back to back.



Bieganski the Blog exists to further explore the themes of the book Bieganski the Brute Polak Stereotype, Its Role in Polish-Jewish Relations and American Popular Culture.
These themes include the false and damaging stereotype of Poles as brutes who are uniquely hateful and responsible for atrocity, and this stereotype's use in distorting WW II history and all accounts of atrocity.
This blog welcomes comments from readers that address those themes. Off-topic and anti-Semitic posts are likely to be deleted.
Your comment is more likely to be posted if:
Your comment includes a real first and last name.
Your comment uses Standard English spelling, grammar, and punctuation.
Your comment uses I-statements rather than You-statements.
Your comment states a position based on facts, rather than on ad hominem material.
Your comment includes readily verifiable factual material, rather than speculation that veers wildly away from established facts.
T'he full meaning of your comment is clear to the comment moderator the first time he or she glances over it.
You comment is less likely to be posted if:
You do not include a first and last name.
Your comment is not in Standard English, with enough errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar to make the comment's meaning difficult to discern.
Your comment includes ad hominem statements, or You-statements.
You have previously posted, or attempted to post, in an inappropriate manner.
You keep repeating the same things over and over and over again.